Author

App Monetization, Research

SOOMLA Webinar # 1 Lotum Case Study on ads and churn

This week we ran our very first webinar at SOOMLA, in an effort to give a bit more visibility and break down to our recent data report on Lotum. The report’s main focus was on the effects of advertising direct competitors on churn and eCPM. Thanks to our very own Yaniv Nizan who took some time to break down the report.

Here is the recording of the webinar! You can find the data report here as well as the full transcript of the webinar below the video.


Start Webinar Transcript

Ben – Hey everyone and welcome to SOOMLA first Webinar, I am Ben Lerner the Director of Marketing and I am joined by our very own CEO, Yaniv Nizan.

Yaniv – Hey, happy to be here, super excited and welcome everyone.

Ben – I’m going to give everyone a very quick intro, these webinars are something we plant o do a monthly basis. There is a lot of great content on our blog including previous reports, but we’re hoping this will help make things a bit more accessible. Today we’re going to be discussing our case study on LOTUM. LOTUM is one of our customers who used Traceback to help gain some really interesting insights. One of which was that specific advertisers resulted in a 3x churn rate, but I think more importantly in all that, it wasn’t quite who they expected.

Before we get into that, Yaniv why don’t explain a bit about SOOMLA and what the Traceback platform is.

Yaniv – Sure, so SOOMLA is an ad measurement platform, and more specifically, we help app publishers measure their monetization. To give you an example, today app publishers don’t know who is advertising in their app, it could a competitor, it could be another app that is taking their users.

Ben – Ahh yes, the infamous black box of advertising that everybody talks about. I’m sure we’ll get more into that, but for now let’s jump straight into the study itself. To give a quick brief on LOTUM, they have a casual word puzzle game called “4 Pics 1 Word” which is available in 8 languages and considered to be one of the top word games in the industry. Yaniv, want to take it from here?

Yaniv – Sounds good, so the context of this report is that we realized that many app developers who used ads, faced the same issue of whether or not to advertise direct competitors.

Ben – Oh yeah absolutely. I personally follow a lot of Indie developer forums being a big gamer myself, and I consistently see issue being raised whenever ad monetization discussion begins.

Yaniv – Yea so the problem is that most app publishers follow their gut feelings when it comes to this. They don’t have any real data to back it up.

Ben – Yea I have seen time and time again – the big warning sign the the skull and crossbones saying – “Don’t allow direct competitors to advertise, they will steal all your users and disappear.”

Yaniv – This sow here Traceback comes in to help Lotus break things down. We can jump into page 3 of the report, and what you can see here is the top 8 advertisers that LOTUM had in the US in the period we measured this. For the purpose of this report we defined Churn as users who clicked on an ad inside the game, but didn’t come back to the game within a 7 day window after clicking on the ad. So if the user did not come back, they are considered to be a churned users. So what you can see here, some of the games like Game of War for example, has 3x more churn. So when Game of War is being advertised in LOTUM app, users that clicked on that are 3x more likely to not come back.

Ben – Really? Okay so seems kind of crazy the nobody has analyzed this until today. Just a question though, what are the actual numbers we are talking about here? Are we talking about churning in the thousands of users, hundreds of users? All I am seeing here are graphical displays.

Yaniv – Yea so this report doesn’t show the exact numbers. Obviously this is confidential information that LOTUM preferred to keep to themselves and we totally respect that for our customers. To give you a range where this could be, typically if we look across all of our customers the churn rate caused by advertisers comes between 3% up to 25% caused by specific advertisers.

Ben – So to fully grasp what you’re talking about, your saying that the potential range is not 3x but closer to 8x. Whats the biggest range you’ve ever seen in a single game?

Yaniv – Yea so 8x is across all the games that we are seeing and I’m saying games, but its also broader than that, as we also have non gaming apps as well. But in a single app or game, we’ve seen a difference of up to 4.5x churn rate between the lowest and highest churning advertiser.

Ben – Wow, but correct me if I’m wrong, isn’t Game of War not a direct competitor to 4 Pics 1 Word?

Yaniv – Yea and this is the part that also surprised us a bit and also Lotum. So Game of War isn’t even a word game and Lotum’s app is. These games are very difference in nature and still this is the advertiser that was taking away the most churn. So when we say this, we wanted to look specifically about whats happening with direct competitors vs non and take the opportunity to dig a little deeper.

Ben – So its literally going completely opposite to whats the industry standard right now.

Yaniv – So as I mentioned before we had a drill down about this specifically. If you look at pages 6 and 7, this is the area where we focused on that. So we looked at all the advertisers and classified them into groups. We didn’t just look at the top eight, but many more. The groups were: Non Games, Other Games and Direct Competitors. For each one of these advertisers we measured two parameters: The churn rate of advertisers in this group and eCPM.

Ben – So thats very interesting and I imagine this means that there is no negative implications for advertising direct competitors. Is it safe to assume that competitors will be paying more to advertise in the app?

Yaniv – Yea so great question, so if you look at page 7, this is what I was saying before. We also measured the eCPM of each one of these groups and what we have seen quite consistently is that direct competitors do pay more to be placed in the app. But as you mentioned before a lot of time there is no negative impact.

Ben – Great so I think these case studies are great but I think a lot of our users would love to see how this has all been possible. Do you think we can spare a few minutes and jump into the Traceback platform itself?

Yaniv – Absolutely, so let’s jump into Traceback. For the sake of this section, we’ll use our demo app called Muffin Rush, which contains a bunch of sample data. So the data is based on one of our live apps, but we masked everything to protect the confidential data of course.

Ben – Yea of course, makes sense. Sow act does it look like once I login, what am I going to start seeing, what data am I going to start seeing? Go for it.

Yaniv – Cool so now that I clicked on the app, I’m int he overview screen once I logged in. This shows you aggregated data and allows you to follow the trends for the app.

Ben – Okay but I see there are some deeper drill down screens. Which one should we be focusing on? I’m thinking the section most most relevant is one that we are looking at advertisers themselves. Can you breakdown what we are looking at?

Yaniv – Yea so on the top menu you can see all the different breakdown screens. One for segmenting and AB testing, another to analyze how ads impact your marketing activity, another how to optimize your waterfall. But as you me toned, the most interesting one for this discussion is the advertiser screen.

Ben – I see you already have the US country filter selected and the interstitial ad types.

Yaniv – Yea so obviously it makes sense to compare advertisers using the same ad format and country, otherwise you’ll be comparing apples to oranges and you don’t want to do that. I can also select different date ranges and change the filters as well.

Ben – Great os it looks pretty intuitive. Each row represents a specific advertiser. Under each one you’re seeing whats the eCPM, whats the total revenue, how many ads were shown etc.

Yaniv – Yea so you can slo control the columns via the three dots on the right to control which columns are being displayed.

Ben – Are there any further drill downs we can go from here?

Yaniv – Yea so if I click on word crossy for example, I get a more specific drill down to them. So this advertiser is coming to my app both through Facebook Ad Network as well as AdMob and actually I can see here that both are paying different eCPMs for this advertiser.

Ben – Well this looks great and I’m sure it has some incredible applications for anybody that knows how to break through all of this data. Tying back to the report itself, LOTUM had asked you guys to produce this report for them, but is this something you do for all of your customers.

Yaniv – Right so we obviously understand that the amount of data can be overwhelming and not everyone has the time to really analyze everything and this is why we assign a dedicated customer success manager who’s job it is to help the customer identify areas where they can improve. This was the case with LOTUM. We gave them this report and allowed them identify different areas to improve.

Ben – Great Yaniv, I wanted to thank you for taking the time to break down the report and more importantly, showing us the the results of Lotus are indeed possible for others given the insights.

Yaniv – Yea was my pleasure and hopefully we’ll run more of these soon with other key features,

Ben – Absolutely. Shout out to everyone for attending. We’ll be posting the recording of the webinar and some of the questions we’ve received throughout. See you all next time for another SOOMLA session. Thanks guys!

End Webinar Transcript

Feel free to share:
App Monetization, Research

Header image - the SOOMLA ads and churn case study is out for Q4 2017, full of insights

We are excited to announce our new “Ads and Churn Case Study with Lotum” report today. This is one of the many industry data reports that we will continue to publish providing important insights related to monetization through ad revenue. Our new reports focuses on the effects of advertising director competitors and their effects on eCPM, churn and seeks to identify which advertisers may be stealing your traffic.

You are welcome to download the report through this link or via the banner to the right.

Would also be great if you can help us spread the word by sharing my post on Linkedin.

Linkedin post about mobile monetization report - q2 2017

 

Feel free to share:
Analytics, App Monetization, Tips and Advice

Easy In-App Events That Can Give You Insight on Your App's Performance

No matter what you are looking to achieve, in-app events are a great way to go about getting performance indicators on some of the central issues faced by your app’s growth. While it might sound great to track every swipe, click, open or close event within your app, it can become a bit overwhelming to make use of all the data.

There is already an established list of benchmarks that should be closely monitored to give you some insights about your app’s performance, however the focus here is to dive into specific in-app events and how they should be approached.

Here is the short list (we could have made it much larger):

Registrations and the dreaded drop-off

Registration drop-offs are the bane of every app. We work so hard to get the quality traffic and the installation, but when it comes to registering – poof they are gone. The golden rule is reduce the amount of steps required for the user to complete the registration. With each additional step, the drop off chance is higher.

Solution – Keep a close eye on your registration drop offs. Identify key steps that are causing it and work to reduce. A/B testing is key here.

Tutorials

Some apps have them, some don’t, but it all depends on how much of an onboarding experience you want to provide the new user. Whether or not they are effective or not, I’ll let you be the judge, however if you do have them, a user’s completion of the tutorial can give you some insight as to how engaged your users are.

Solution – Overall on-boarding completion is a good metric to keep an eye on, however if the number is significantly low, it would be worthwhile to set up multiple in-app events for various stages to check out where the drop-offs are occurring.

User Progression

How quickly your user’s progress through your beginning game content is a great identifier on how your app is performing, but also can give you great insights on which users to segment and target specifically. Conversely, those users who move through the content slow should also be identified.

Solution – Logging several events throughout (beginning, middle, end), should be examined to monitor drop-offs and provide some insights on how engaged your users are.

Video Ads Completion

There are a multitude of parameters to look at and analyze when considering how effective your video ads are. Several studies have been put out, but the macro trends show that there has been a big shift towards video ads and its respective portion of ad revenue.

Where you place your ads within your app and how frequently can influence your revenue, uninstall rate, player experience and many other key KPIs.

Solution – Monitor and A/B test the placement and frequency of your video ads. They can have a big effect, but also have the potential to damage your app’s overall performance. Also be sure to check out our post on optimizing your opt-in rate for video ads which can help boost your ad revenue significantly.

FREE REPORT – VIDEO ADS RETENTION IMPACT

In-App Purchases

If your app has in-app purchases, an obvious tell-tale how your app is performing is how many of your users are making purchases. It is a great indicator of how engaging your app is, be it either via content or level of addiciton. A user’s purchasing behaviour can then be leveraged for future purchases. Knowing what your users have purchased and how much they have spent in the past are key for segmenting promotions and sales for specific users.

Solution – If the frequency of in-app purchases are very low, try to lower the costs / increase the offer to entice users. The ultimate goal is finding that sweet spot between making the in-app purchases valuable but not too much so that they make it too easy for the user.

Conclusion

Very likely each app has it’s own category specific in-app event that is closely monitored, however we tried to focus on the basics that touch on many different types of apps. We hope that this list helps you gain some insights on how your app is performing.

If you can think of any other critical in-app events that should be added to this list, let us know!

 
 

Feel free to share:
App Monetization, Resource

Top 5 Mobile Retention Software : Apsalar, Urban Airship, Swrve, AppSee, Localytics, Countly

Thinking about successful companies like Facebook, Google or Instagram, one thing comes up as an underlying factor for all of them and that is – sustainable growth. We are long past the point where download numbers acts as the main success metric. We now know that the majority of mobile users end up deleting the app after the first 72 hours, so retaining as many as possible becomes essential.

Tech giants and investors are realizing that if your app has a ‘user leak’ somewhere, throwing money into ads, manipulating push notifications and incentivizing new downloads doesn’t do the trick. The solution then comes in the form of retention software solutions. Opportunities to surprise, delight and retain your customers as well as create unique experiences for them are increasing due to the level of detailed data available out there. Product iteration (“updatability”), incentivizing users, mobile personalization of apps and new developments in push notification all make for amazing retention capabilities.

With such a vibrant field, we decided to do some digging to find the best retention software available out there. Here is our honest take on the pros and cons of the top 5 retention software available to you today. Note, the list is not written in a particular order.

We also wrote up an in-depth full post on the comparison between ad networks. This will help provide all the details needed for choosing the right Ad Network for your mobile app. Check out the article or download the full comparison spreadsheet below for free.
 

FREE AD NETWORK COMPARISON SPREADSHEET

 

Apsalar logo - a video ad networkApsalar

We start our list off with Apsalar that recently merged with Singular to bring us a pretty robust marketing analytics platform. The platform offers a lifecycle management solution for both marketers and mobile app developers. The main focus of the platform is to get the right users for you, to analyze them, offer great analytics and give advice on how to target your users with various campaigns. Similar to Google Analytics, but yet different since Apsalar focused on mobile from the start. It can offer actionable analytics, which will help you keep an eye on your revenue, user engagement as well as retention. Here are some pros and cons of the platform

Pros Cons
Segment comparison (user segmentation as well) No custom dashboard
Engagement analysis No messaging service
Can acquire users for you
Create funnels
Analytics across multiple apps
Free tool that allows specific user targeting

Urban Airship logoUrban Airship

Mobile engagement company founded back in 2009 in the US. Combining app push messages, proximity targeting and analytics, the company has focused on vertical growth and industries such as media and entertainment, retail, sports, travel and hospitality. They cover companies such as ABS news, Adidas and Virgin Galactic to name a few. The company pushes over 10 billion messages a month to over 2 billion active app installs.

Pros Cons
Free Trial pricy
Amazing throughput
High security
Real time retention package

SwrveSwrve

Some would call it a comprehensive mobile marketing platform, which in a sense it is. The dashboard is offered with numerous iterations to suit anyone’s taste. Funnels, cohort analysis, vanity, retention, monetization, all of these tools can be located on the main dashboard which allows for quick access and adjustments. Besides push notifications, the bread and butter of the company is app analytics, A/B testing as well as in app campaigns. It managed to secure business from the likes of Electronic Arts, Sony and Warner Bros. Here are some pros and cons of this platform.

Pro Cons
Segmentation capabilities which allow push message personalization Pricing not published publicly on the site
Analytic tools for A/B testing Web interface is a bit clunky
Great dashboard Pricy
 

FREE REPORT – VIDEO ADS RETENTION IMPACT

 


AppSeeAppSee

This platform has a very unique approach to marketing. In essence it’s a visual in-app analytics platform. What does this mean? By stimulating you with various visuals (and numerous colors), the platform helps you measure, understand and improve the user’s experience. With “classic” analytics you also get an additional bonus of getting access to information on users’ behavior. They provide you with real user sessions so that you can understand what happens and when (example: why users don’t finish their registration form). Heatmaps are very intuitively designed and can help you tons in figuring out where your users focus. User interaction will lead to events creation which, in turn, you can use to create conversion funnels in the platform itself. Some pros and cons:

Pro Cons
Unique visuals Pricy
Free Trial Customizability finite
Playback recordings of user sessions
Automatic integration
Crash recording

LocalyticsLocalytics

A very good mobile analytics and marketing platform that covers Android, iPhone, iPad, HTML5, Windows apps and Blackberry. Like Appsee, Localytics also offers the ability to monitor user behavior on mobile and web devices, but in real time. The company was founded in 2009 and now supports over 37 000 apps, their grit has lead them to land business with Skype, HBO, eBay, Microsoft and other big names. The whole idea of the platform is to take action based on insights that you get from watching users interact with apps in real time, they tied in a marketing add-on that will let you target users for specific actions. Here are our pros and cons for Localytics:

Pros Applovin
Real time engagement tracking A bit tricky to integrate
User insights – trend tracking in retention No external API
Personalized messages, ads and campaigns No change graph for funnels
Great support Data not delivered in real time
Sending in app messages and push notifications

CountlyBonus: Countly

We just couldn’t resist to add Countly to our list, it is not one of the leading analytics tools however it has a unique position, great UI and an intuitive design. It is dear to us since it is an open source mobile analytics application, which offers data in real time, with an easy to use dashboard and all info you need at a glance. It lacks some segmentation options that the leaders in the field have, but if you’re looking for a free and helpful solution, we would recommend this cool platform.

Conclusion

Though your favorite platform may not be on the list, we tried to focus on elements that will make your life easier when utilizing the platform such as user-friendly interface, customization ability, multiple OS, user retention capabilities, or push notification functionality. We hope that this list helps you find your favorite mobile retention software solution.

Feel free to share:

DOWNLOAD OUR RECENT REPORT

Join 7905 other smart people who get email updates for free!

We don't spam!

Unsubscribe any time

Categories

Archives